Skip to content
MoneyKiwi

GuideCars & Transport

How to choose a panel beater in New Zealand

How to choose a panel beater in NZ: claiming through your car insurer, choosing a repairer, comparing quotes for private repairs, and checking the work afterwards.

MBy MoneyKiwi Editorial TeamUpdated

Whether it's a scraped bumper or a serious crash, how you pay for repairs changes how you choose a panel beater.

Repairs through your insurer

  1. Report the damage to your insurer as soon as you can, with photos and the other driver's details if someone else was involved.
  2. Your insurer may assess the car itself or ask for a repair quote.
  3. Check your policy wording. Some insurers have a list of preferred repairers, and some let you choose your own. Ask what happens to your warranty and excess either way.
  4. You usually pay your excess. If the other driver was at fault and is identified, you may be able to get it back.

Read our car insurance guide for how excesses and claims work.

Paying for repairs yourself

For small damage, paying privately can be cheaper than claiming once you count your excess and any effect on your no-claims bonus.

Quotes vs estimates

  • A quote is generally a firm price. Once you accept it, the business can't charge more unless you agree to extra work or the job changes.
  • An estimate is an educated guess. The final bill can differ, so ask how far it might move.
  • Get quotes from at least three businesses, in writing, for the same scope of work. If prices differ a lot, ask why.

What to ask a panel beater

  • Will they use new genuine parts, aftermarket parts or repaired parts?
  • How will they match the paint, and is the paint work guaranteed?
  • How long will the car be off the road, and is a courtesy car available?
  • What warranty do they give on the repair?

Checking the work

When you pick your car up, look at it in daylight. Check paint colour and finish, panel gaps, lights and that warning lights are off. Raise any problems straight away.

Your rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act

When you pay a business for a service, it must be done:

  • with reasonable care and skill
  • so it's fit for the purpose you asked for
  • within a reasonable time, if no time was agreed
  • for a reasonable price, if no price was agreed

If the work isn't up to standard, you can ask them to fix it. If they refuse or take too long, you can get it fixed elsewhere and claim the cost, or cancel. For a serious failure you can cancel and ask for a refund, and you can claim for other losses the failure caused.

If you claimed through insurance and the repair is poor, contact your insurer too. If you can't resolve it, insurers belong to a free dispute resolution scheme.

Red flags

  • Asking you to inflate a claim, or to pay cash so the insurer "won't need to know"
  • No written quote or invoice
  • Refusing to say what parts were used

Questions people ask

Can I choose my own panel beater for an insurance claim?

It depends on your policy. Some insurers use preferred repairers and some let you choose. Check your policy wording and ask your insurer.

Should I claim on insurance for minor damage?

Compare the repair quote with your excess and any loss of no-claims bonus. For small jobs, paying privately can work out cheaper.

What's the difference between a quote and an estimate?

A quote is generally a firm price that can't go up unless you agree to extra work or the job changes. An estimate is an educated guess, so the final bill can differ.

Sources

MoneyKiwi provides general information only. It is not financial advice and does not take your personal circumstances into account. Consider talking to a licensed financial adviser before making financial decisions. Read our disclaimer.

Interests

We'll email you to confirm. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Keep reading